Thursday, January 15, 2009

bike seat or trailer? Yes!

Like many parents who eagerly wait for the day their baby’s neck can handle both a helmeted head and potholes (doctors recommend 12 months), Michael and I debated: bike seat or trailer? One and a half years into our family biking adventure, we’ve learned that the answer is: “Yes!”

Disclaimer: For us, biking with Miguel is an easy choice. We don’t have a car, and are used to hauling all kinds of things by bike, from groceries to a washer and dryer set (which messed up the trailer hitch, but that's another story.) Our basement is easy to access, our foyer is large and we are the landlords of a bike-friendly building; we have the room and permission to stash our two-wheeled accoutrements where we please. We also only have one child. So, the biking-with-kid learning/logistics curve might not be as steep for us as for others.

Sometimes I worry that we paint too rosy a view of our bike-dependent lifestyle. It takes time, skill, patience, a sense of humor and a tolerance for Weather. But so do all forms of transportation. For example, I have the patience to spend a few minutes at a bike rack, puzzling through the “Ooops, I bought too many groceries” pannier challenge, but would claw my eyes out in a car circling for a spot in the Whole Foods parking lot. No way of getting around is perfect, which, to get back to what I started writing about, is why we use both a bike seat and trailer.

The bike seat gives Miguel a better view and is less cumbersome in traffic and when parked. It's our choice for shorter, fairer weather trips. Our model came with a highly engineered red poncho that fits over the helmet, kid and seat, so we do not fear summer cloudbursts.

I had been initially reluctant to use a seat, worried that the bike would tip over with Miguel in it. But so long as I have something to lean my frame against, getting him in and out is no problem. One downside is that it eliminates rear rack carrying capacity. We compensate with a front basket or pannier, and could hitch up one of our cargo trailers, but usually I just don’t plan to carry or buy a lot during bike seat outings. (Who wants to do big shopping trips with a 2 year old anyway??)

The trailer has been invaluable during the last two frigid, snowy winters and for longer journeys when we want Miguel to be able to take a nap. The rolling cocoon provides weather protection and room for snacks, books and toys while liberating the rear rack for carrying other gear. But it can be cumbersome to park and store.

Another challenge of trailers is that they extend behind you, which can make turning, going through intersections, even changing lanes a little nerve-wracking. You have to be hawkeyed about clearance and signal your intentions assertively. You get used it though, and drivers tend to give a wide berth.

Our trailer is just for one kid, so it has a narrow profile, which I like for urban commuting. But it does not have a "helmet well" in the back, so Miguel's head is pushed forward a bit by the back wall. This is a feature I would look for if buying a new trailer.

Michael and I have attachments for the seat and trailer, so it’s easy for us to switch off. For example, when Michael drops him off at day care, he leaves the trailer or bike seat there. That way I can pick him up (though I haven’t done that in a while—thanks, Michael!) We are grateful that our day care provider lets us and another biking family store our trailers in their gangway and the bike seats with all the other strollers.

I suspect that we’ll be biking a little less in the near future though. For while it’s a great choice for us, Miguel’s answer to bike seat or trailer is: “Bus!” or “Train!” And he’s right. While we’re pedaling, he’s sitting behind us. Our focus is more on traffic than on talking with him. By contrast, transit journeys involve walking, talking, observing, and, of course, a very exciting bus or train with big wheels, loud noises and interesting people. I want to say that I look forward to the day that he can ride a bike with us. . . but I don’t think I am quite ready for that level of independence! For now, I don’t mind slowing down and mixing up the modes (and modes within modes) a bit.

No comments: